Why Did Michelle Carter Want Conrad to Die? What Motivated Her Disturbing Actions?

Why did Michelle Carter want Conrad to die? If you’re curious about why Michelle Carter wanted her boyfriend to die, continue reading for a recap of the case, her release, and the motivations behind her text messages to Roy about taking his own life.

Why Did Michelle Carter Want Conrad to Die?

In 2014, Conrad Roy died by suicide through carbon monoxide poisoning. Text messages between Roy and his girlfriend, Michelle Carter, came to light during the investigation, suggesting Carter’s involvement in encouraging his suicide. 

The prosecution argued that Carter wanted Roy to die for various reasons. Carter and Roy had met in 2012 and had a long-distance relationship. Their text exchanges leading up to Roy’s death indicated that they considered themselves romantically involved. 

Roy’s suicide involved him sitting in his truck with a generator running, and Carter allegedly instructed him to get back into the truck, ultimately leading to his death. 

Many of their texts contained messages encouraging Roy’s suicidal thoughts, with Carter even assuring him that she would take care of his family after his demise.

Carter organized a charity baseball game in Roy’s honor after his death, but suspicions arose due to the event’s location in her own town. Testimony from a classmate revealed that Carter was clingy and sought attention. 

She also confessed her responsibility for Roy’s death in texts to her classmate, expressing guilt for her role.

During the trial, Carter’s mental health issues, including anxiety, depression, and anorexia, were discussed. The defense argued that her struggles prevented her from understanding the gravity of suicide and that she genuinely believed it was the best outcome for Roy. 

However, the judge convicted Carter of involuntary manslaughter in 2017, as she had chosen a trial without a jury.

The case highlighted the impact of digital communication on suicide cases and raised complex questions about responsibility, mental health, and the boundaries of interpersonal relationships.

Michelle Carter Has Been Released From Jail

Michelle Carter, who was sentenced to 15 months in prison and five years of probation for encouraging her boyfriend’s suicide through text messages, appealed her case to the Supreme Court, arguing that the First Amendment protected her texts. 

However, her appeal was denied. Carter’s lawyer expressed disappointment, stating that the Court missed an opportunity to address issues related to mental illness, adolescent psychology, and social media. 

Despite the denial of her appeal, Carter was released from the Bristol County House of Correction in Massachusetts. She was seen leaving the jail wearing the same clothes she had on when she entered. 

Carter, now 23 years old, was accompanied by law enforcement to a waiting black Jeep, where her mother was. 

Reports indicate that she spent her time in jail gardening and taking academic classes, and she was photographed embracing her mother upon her release.

Final Thoughts

In 2015, the nation became captivated by the case of Michelle Carter, a teenager accused of using text messages to persuade her boyfriend, Conrad Roy, to take his own life. 

Over several weeks, Carter sent Roy numerous texts encouraging him to commit suicide. Tragically, Roy followed through with her suggestions in July 2014. 

Less than eight months later, Carter faced charges of involuntary manslaughter in Massachusetts and was ultimately sentenced to 15 months in jail after her trial in 2017. She began serving her sentence in early 2019.

The HBO documentary I Love You, Now Die, released in July 2019, shed light on Michelle Carter’s case and introduced many people to her story. 

Although her appeal was denied in January 2020, Carter, the central figure in the suicide-by-texting case, is now a free woman. She was released from jail on January 23, 2020.